What Is Water Pie – Melancholy-Era H2o Pie Recipe

Kandace Wysock

Table of Contents A A little bit Wonky, Melancholy-Period Cake That is Stood the Exam of Time The Melancholy-Period Dish That Motivated My Family’s Favored Thanksgiving Recipe The very last gasp of summer months is substantial time for pie earning. Fruits that have spent months softening in the solar are […]

The very last gasp of summer months is substantial time for pie earning. Fruits that have spent months softening in the solar are at their greatest when paired with a flaky, buttery crust. But what if I had been to tell you that recently, a sure pie caught my eye that requirements no fruit at all? In fact, this pie demands so few ingredients that its principal ingredient is drinking water.

Drinking water pie, a Despair-Period recipe, has been creating rounds on the net. It’s not a nickname: The filling in h2o pie is in reality mainly h2o. There are, of course, other components that aid differentiate the pie from a cold glass of Evian. There is flour, butter and sugar—but actually, not a lot else.

H2o pie initial caught my consideration on TikTok, in which B. Dylan Hollis (@bdylanhollis), a “mid-century connoisseur,” who attempts his hand at a selection of classic recipes, surfaced the creation for one of his videos. “Can you bake a pie with 4 ingredients?” he suggests, amassing the very small component record. “Yes! But I’d instead try to eat my mattress.”

Hollis proceeds to blend and roll out a pie dough, lay it into a tin and par-bake. When out of the oven, he fills the crust directly with water, sugar, some flour, and pats of butter. He mixes it incredibly very little (maybe not at all) then pops it again into the oven. Upon tasting the completed product or service, he screws up his facial area in disgust and proclaims it preferences like “soggy lint.”

I arrived at out to Hollis, who suggests he “came across the recipe printed in a community cookbook titled 90th Anniversary Cookbook – Gals of United Methodist Church, Gordon Nebraska.” As a collector of vintage recipes, he was drawn to a section of the cookbook that showcased recipes from the Great Melancholy. What we know as a h2o pie, was referred to in the book as Tough Moments Pie 1929. “Immediately, what stuck out to me was the entire lack of spices or flavoring,” he claims. “The filling merely called for drinking water, flour, and sugar. A lot of on line iterations 1 finds of the Drinking water Pie consist of vanilla extract, having said that this printed recipe clearly took its title of ‘Hard Times’ earnestly.”

As he so aptly demonstrates in his TikTok, the water pie still left a little something to be desired (“the taste was that of gelatinous, sodden dough”). BuzzFeed’s Erin Phraner, having said that, had one thing of a diverse working experience with her own h2o pie. Also a retro recipe fanatic, Phraner experienced stored the concept of creating a drinking water pie in her back again pocket for some time. It wasn’t until the peak of the pandemic and the first lockdown that she considered to ultimately split out just one of the wackiest recipes in her arsenal.

The video was a hit. “I did not count on it to go as viral as it did. It was foolish and magical and essentially actually delectable (in particular to someone like me who has a mega sweet tooth),” she stated. “I think I have seen a large amount of people produce about it from the Despair-Period standpoint but that was not it for me at all. It was far more about performing a little something foolish and out-of-the-box to just shake off the heaviness of the calendar year.”

There have to be some correlation amongst the existing minute and drinking water pie’s resurgence. I imagined back again to Clara Cannucciari, who created a YouTube empire off of her videos in which she cooked her way through the recipes that saved her relatives alive in the course of one of America’s darkest chapters. An appreciation for the homegrown and the simplistic flourished throughout lockdown, was water pie 1 such illustration? Hollis seems to feel so:

“We can’t deny the parallels our recent COVID-19 pandemic shares with the Great Despair. Lots of of us are however trapped inside of, funds is shorter, and the hindrances to feeding on out in community has compelled us to return to our kitchens and reflect on it as a spot to develop and sustain us extra than ever prior to. Baking historic recipes is 1 of the most intriguing and partaking strategies to experience the past, and via that: understand our place in the current time.”

Would you make a drinking water pie? Do you have any preferred Depression-Era recipes? Convey to us about them in the opinions!

Next Post


Congratulations to Chefs Jim Shirley and Michelle Bernstein who will be honored at The 2021 Florida Cafe & Lodging Demonstrate with the Torch and Beacon Awards, respectively. These two cafe industry leaders will be acknowledged for their superb achievements and dedication to the Southeast restaurant industry all through the conference […]